IW Meeting 2012-03-15

From Inference Web

Jump to: navigation, search

Contents

Meeting Information

Agenda

  • Administrative
  • Around the room - please post online in advance
  • Outstanding TODOs
  • RETURN TOs
  • Focus: indicator-based presentations with potential tie ins to datacube / d3

Attendees

  • Tim
  • Deborah
  • Amar
  • James
  • Cynthia
  • Joanne
  • Paulo

Meeting Preparation

Around the room

(fill this out before meeting)

Jim M.

  • Mapped FRBR and FRIR to PROV
    • frbr has relations that are prov:wasDerivedBy and/or prov:alternateOf
  • Worked on LOBI, which will be a resource for sharing experimental descriptions. The base demonstration site will include all 12,000+ experiments from ArrayExpress, which will be converted using magetab2rdf.
  • Will be working on lit review of the use of metamodeling in provenance and data cubes. Known lit suggestions are more than welcome.

no returns

Tim

no returns

James

RETURN TO: presentation  which will connect to cynthia's demo

Deborah

  • fuse evaluation meeting participation - outcome is focus for james and cynthia on presentation options and and prototypes
  • sent email to usgs contact for additional provenance requirements - awaiting input - will impact class extensions to semantaqua
  • IPAW work
    • Tim's
    • Jim's
    • others?

no returns

cynthia

 in particular but all - - we need you to fill this in in advance

(we're taking notes below!)

RETURN cynthia's demo

  Paulo

PNNL is generating PMLP on people, orgs, publications, instruments. Going to triple store.

-question from deborah - is that available externally? :-) :-/ :-(   No>:-{   

  • would be nice to have RPI and UTEP do the same thing. UTEP is in process of doing it.

- but UTEP is doing it for UTEP info - where is that available? TODO _ paulo send pointer when it is available - as part of  i3 initiative 

TODO: Paulo show an example, so we can consider reproducing it.

tool "alfescho" tool, integrating derivia into alfescho. alfresho is a "drupal alternative" implemetned in java. Easy to get java into it. antonio coming up to PNNL. alfrehsco is integrated to semantic media wiki https://www.alfresco.com/ 

  • alfereacho CMS
  • CAT - data management system on top of lfaesscho
  • VELO is a web based access to CAT. Cool things like connecting to super computers.

7 year development.

  • reviewed a paper, has comments.

RETURN TO paper that Paulo reviewed

Outstanding action items

  • - paulo will call deborah, cynthia on the  issues jiao brought (cc inference web) also send an email first with the  questions and cynthia's provisional answers to inference-web  
  • paulo sent comments on the first round of jiao's input.  Cynthia forwarded a second round of comments
  • Paulo: they were all "tertiary" concepts less interesting than secondary.
  • TODO: Paulo review/respond to Cynthia's comments. about jiao
  • done: Paulo tell Deborah about Paulo's interest in community science.
    • DOE, NREL, Jim Hendler, data.gov, etc.
    • is there followup we should do here?  i gave a talk at NREL a few years ago on our semantic escience work
    • PNNL is funded by a branch of science - they care about how science can benefit a broader community.  broader than EERE (what is that?) ERE? Office of DOE for renewable energy
    • TODO: Paulo and Deborah follow up on open science. - in particular with respect to DOE interests.
  • let rest: Cynthia ask Patrick about twc local titanpad.
    • nothing new. last heard, we have one. Evan did. Needs to be brought up to date, apply patches. Patrick will decide which machine.
    • TODO: CYnthai to resend message and make sure EVan and Patrick knwo we want it.
  • REMAINS: Cynthia to point admin to Try this: http://tldp.org/HOWTO/Apache-WebDAV-LDAP-HOWTO/
  • let rest: James model the confirming/disconfirming examples using ths property. (hasConfidence)  - focus has changed to conflicts from confirming/disconfirming
  • RETURN TO pml api licensing
  • RETURN TO PML api to github as open source
  • RETURN TO: Deborah to approve move to github.
  • ONGOING: Paulo to ask if he an use svn with right license BSD.
  • TODO REMAINS: Paulo send Tim email about data.gov Chris (main SW architect of data.gov). State interest about opening sci data. Tim will pass on to Chris.
  • RETURN TO conversion tool and CAT. 
  • TODO REMAINS: Tim and Paulo discuss CAT += csv2rdf4lod offline

Today's discussions

Around the room

handled above 

Outstanding TODOs 

handled above

RETURN TOs

James

Deborah's preamble:

Indicators  for "emergence" of technology based on indicators. Cynthia has taken 2  traces and presented in a UI -"for free" but UI too geeky.  James's  powerpoint attemps to put it into perspective. 

What is an "indicator" in fuse's context?

http://browser.inference-web.org/iwbrowser/NodeSetBrowser?url=https://tw1.tw.rpi.edu/fuse/hypothesis/emergence_hypothesis_3.owl%23Hyp99_NodeSet

on to presentation

https://tw1.tw.rpi.edu/fuse/rpi/Presentations/IWTelecon-3-15_IndicatorPresentationInCADRE.ppt

Need axioms specified - need also to be documented with comments.  where did this knowledge come from.

Cynthia

show what we can do for free in iw browser

Paulo - paper reviewed

interesting point identified by McCusker -  - evidence is that a new journal was launched.  No information about whether that journal is still around - at the end of this related document group but possibly also checking to see if this journal is still around on the outside web a higher level perspective on this comment is what might make this indicator more believable or less believable as a strong indicator of community of practice

Facts about IW Meeting 2012-03-15RDF feed
Date15 March 2012  +
Personal tools
Navigation